You know how they say “don’t judge a book by its cover”?
Well, I’m so glad I ignored that advice.
I was wandering through my library when a book I’d never seen before just stopped me in my tracks. ‘The Crossroads at Midnight‘. I had zero context. Never heard of the book, never heard of the author, Abby Howard.

But the cover art? It just grabbed me. It was atmospheric, a little creepy, and I immediately knew I had to check it out.
First Impressions: This Isn’t Your Average Graphic Novel
Right away, I noticed this book feels different. This isn’t your typical glossy, full-color graphic novel. The pages are thick, and the art inside is all stark, gorgeous black-and-white ink. It has a fantastic, almost manga-like quality to it that perfectly sets the moody, unsettling tone for what’s to come.
So, Who Is Abby Howard?
I was so impressed that I immediately had to look her up. The book itself is a bit mysterious about its creator, but the website (The Last Halloween) filled in the blanks.
Get this: Howard studied Evolutionary Biology, but after being a contestant on the web reality show Strip Search, she was able to pivot and chase her dream of being a full-time cartoonist. (Talk about a cool origin story!)
She’s been in the game for nearly a decade, and The Crossroads at Midnight is her first short horror collection. She also co-founded a game studio, Black Tabby Games, with her spouse, and they’re working on an episodic horror game called Scarlet Hollow. This author clearly lives and breathes the horror genre, and it shows in her work.
What It’s About: Five Stories That Will Haunt You
‘The Crossroads at Midnight’ is a collection of five chilling short stories. As I read them, I noticed a powerful, creeping theme tying them all together: feelings of intense isolation, loneliness, and crushing responsibility.
Each story feels distinct, but they all share that same quiet, unsettling heartbeat.
No spoilers, I promise! But here’s a quick peek at what you’re in for:
- The Girl in the Fields: A young girl, feeling smothered by her conservative family, befriends a mysterious girl living on the other side of a fence.
- Mattress, Used: A broke college kid does the one thing you should never do: he brings home a mattress he found on the street. It… does not go well.
- The Boy From the Sea: A younger sister, feeling abandoned as her older sister grows up, befriends a strange boy while on vacation.
- Our Lake Monsters: A girl has grown up with her family’s “pet” lake monster and is fiercely, unsettlingly loyal to it.
- Kindred Spirits: An older woman living alone on the edge of a bog has a… peculiar houseguest.
My Final Take: 5/5 Stars
Honestly, there wasn’t a single story in this collection that I didn’t love.
If I had to pick one that felt slightly different from the others, it might be “Mattress, Used,” but it was still a fantastic, creepy read that absolutely belonged in the collection.
And the art. Seriously. Don’t let the black-and-white style fool you into thinking it’s simple. Howard is a master of using light and shadow to build dread. The lack of color honestly makes the horror more effective.
This has, hands down, rocketed onto my list of all-time favorite horror graphic novels.
I’m not the only one who loved it—I saw a great post on the subreddit r/graphicnovels that perfectly captured why this book works so well.
If you are a fan of horror, the macabre, or just brilliantly told short stories with art that will stick with you, you need to read this book.







